
Added · Daily discovery
Eight minus six was the easy part. The unusual bit was getting the answer from someone who was asleep. In a 2021 study led by Karen R. Konkoly and colleagues, a participant heard the subtraction problem during a nap and looked left then right twice to signal two. When the question was repeated, he gave the same answer. Figure 2 in the paper lets you see both replies on the recording.
The participant was having a lucid dream: he realised he was dreaming while still asleep. He had learnt a separate eye signal to tell the researchers when that happened. To establish that the exchanges took place during rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep, sleep specialists independently examined recordings of brain activity, eye movements and muscle tone. Other raters scored the response signals.
Four groups in the United States, Germany, France and the Netherlands pooled results from different experiments. In the French arm, an experienced lucid dreamer sometimes replied with facial muscle contractions. Sorbonne Université’s account describes the contrast neatly: the experimenter could ask questions aloud, and the sleeper could answer with a smile or a frown. After waking, he described the experimenter’s voice as part of the scene in his dream. That scene comes from his account after waking. The physiological recording captured his reply.
The teams tested 36 people. Six gave correct replies at least once. Table 2 counts 29 correct replies in 158 attempts during REM sleep with signalled lucidity. No reply was the most common outcome. The experiment shows that an ordinary question can sometimes reach a sleeper and get an answer that can be scored. Its numbers tell you how often the channel stayed quiet.
Source details & what was checked
- Karen R. Konkoly, Kristoffer Appel, Emma Chabani and colleagues · Online 18 February 2021. Current Biology 31(7), issue dated 12 April 2021. DOI 10.1016/j.cub.2021.01.026.
Read the article introduction, relevant results and discussion, Figure 2 caption, Table 2 and sleep/signal-scoring methods. PDF includes supplements. Videos, raw traces and every supplemental interaction were outside inspection.
Real-time dialogue between experimenters and dreamers during REM sleep (external source, opens a new tab) · In the source library - Sorbonne Université institutional communiqué, with comments by Delphine Oudiette (Inserm / Institut du Cerveau) · 19 February 2021
Read the explanation of prior one-way signalling, the French task examples, deliberately different facial muscle replies, the dreamer’s attributed recollection and the experimental proof-of-concept limits.
Communiquer pendant nos rêves, c’est possible ! (external source, opens a new tab) · In the source library